In a report despatched to Rigzone late Tuesday by Normal Chartered Financial institution Head of Commodities Analysis Paul Horsnell, analysts on the firm, together with Horsnell, stated “the trail of oil costs in October thus far has been as erratic as its September gyrations”.
“From an intra-day low beneath $70 per barrel on 1 October to a excessive above $81 per barrel on 7 and eight October after which a reversal to beneath $73.50 per barrel in early buying and selling on 15 October,” the analysts highlighted within the report, including that the Brent ahead curve “stays very flat, with an nearly parallel downwards shift over the previous week”.
The analysts said within the report that it is perhaps tempting to elucidate the strikes greater and decrease when it comes to some form of threat premium that inflated and deflated in line with headlines however stated they assume the entire idea of threat premium is moderately lazy.
- Advertisement -
“It may be used to completely clarify value strikes looking back however has no predicative energy or perception,” they famous within the report.
“As an alternative of the market completely pricing threat each day, we predict market dynamics have been much less refined,” they added.
“The prevailing tone of market sentiment, significantly among the many extra speculative merchants, stays overwhelmingly bearish, on a par with that in late 2008 in the beginning of the World Monetary Disaster,” they warned.
The Normal Chartered analysts highlighted within the report that the dominant oil market narrative is at present based mostly on theories of macroeconomic onerous landings, excessive oil demand weak spot, and base circumstances of oversupplied 2025 oil markets.
“We predict that narrative is wrong, however it’s the prism which present value dynamics need to be seen via,” they stated.
“Geopolitical considerations can sometimes trigger funds to maneuver to a much less aggressively brief place, however any perceived rest of circumstances brings the shorts again, usually inside hours,” they added.
“We don’t assume the market is reacting to something geopolitical past merely the dangers of direct assaults on Iran’s power infrastructure. Merchants will not be pricing within the potential for longer-term adjustments in Iran’s international relations, and even Iranian reactions to any additional assaults on it,” they continued.
“Briefly, the oil market is probably not a superb supply of nuanced geopolitical evaluation, and evidently solely probably the most excessive short-term outcomes are able to inflicting shorts to pause,” they went on to state.
The analysts additionally warned within the report that the middle of the bearishness has moved from Brent to WTI.
“Our WTI money-manager positioning index fell week on week and is now decrease than our Brent positioning index, however each indices counsel there may be nonetheless important scope for additional shorting,” they stated.
“The most recent transfer down has additionally taken costs right into a area the place gamma results change into a consideration once more; this raises the opportunity of sharper short-term falls as banks search safety for his or her producer hedging-related choices positions,” they famous.
The analysts said within the report that when the mud of the short-term headlines clears they assume costs will drift greater once more.
“We predict that market reactions that see the geopolitical scenario as merely a collection of short-term tit-for-tat strikes are underpricing the dangers of a extra important and doubtlessly chaotic watershed in Center East geopolitics,” they added.
In a market evaluation despatched to Rigzone this morning, Michael Brown, a Senior Analysis Strategist at Pepperstone, highlighted that, yesterday, Brent and WTI “barrel[ed]… over 5 p.c decrease apiece amid one thing of an ideal storm for the bulls”.
Brown described this “excellent storm” as “studies that Israel wouldn’t goal Iranian power infrastructure in deliberate retaliation towards Iran; continued fallout from China’s lackluster fiscal stimulus, amid rumors that ‘nothing substantial’ is on the best way when it comes to measures to spice up consumption; plus, individuals persevering with to digest OPEC having trimmed international demand projections for the third month operating”.
“Whereas WTI has now fallen as a lot as seven p.c in simply two classes to kick-off this buying and selling week, I nonetheless view brief crude positions via a uncertain lens, significantly with the geopolitical scenario remaining fluid, and the market having priced out a major chunk of threat premium on the again of a sole ‘sources’ report,” Brown added.
“Crude bears could be properly suggested to not get too grasping right here, and a few earnings from the brief facet may properly be taken off the desk in comparatively brief order. Complacency over developments within the Center East is unlikely to serve individuals properly,” he continued.
In one other market evaluation despatched to Rigzone on Tuesday, Joseph Dahrieh, Managing Principal at Tickmill, stated “tensions eased following reassurances from Israel that it’ll not goal Iranian oil infrastructure”.
“This diminished considerations round potential provide disruptions tied to the continued Center East battle. In consequence, the fizzling geopolitical threat premium may drive oil costs down because the fast hazard diminishes,” he added.
“In the meantime, weak international demand projections, significantly from China, have additional weighed on oil markets. OPEC just lately downgraded its oil demand development forecast 2024 whereas China’s September oil imports dropped, reflecting weak home demand,” he continued.
Dahrieh additionally said within the evaluation that record-high U.S. oil manufacturing and softening demand have put further pressure on costs.
“Whereas geopolitical tensions may proceed to lend some assist and stop sharper declines, sluggish financial development within the Eurozone and China suggests a risky and doubtlessly bearish outlook for crude costs within the close to time period,” he warned.
To contact the writer, electronic mail andreas.exarheas@rigzone.com
